Benny Stivale’s

Eating at Benny Stivale’s is like taking a step back into the 90s. Known for their comically large pizzas (pro tip: eat at the bar facing Main Street and watch customers try and fit the pizza box in their cars), Benny Stivale’s keeps the menu simple with a couple of featured slices for the week along with pizza favorites like pepperoni and mushroom. Head further back from the counter and find a bar filled with local craft beer. Keep going and you’ll end up in Waynesboro’s secret beer garden with plenty of room to enjoy a beer and a slice and play some yard games.